Choosing the Route
The choice of the route the train would take from Oak Bluffs through Edgartown to Katama was was a big debate. Some wanted the route to go inland and west of Sengekontacket Pond, while others wanted the route to go down Nantucket Sound along the beach parallel to the Edgartown - Oak Bluffs road.
The reason some people wanted the route to go west of Sengekontacket
Pond was that they were concerned that the train would frighten
all of the horses that travel along the Edgartown - Oak Bluffs
road. Others wanted it to travel along the beach because it offered
a magnificent view, was shorter, and less expensive. Since the
main reason for some people not wanting the beach route was the
engine scaring the horses it was decided to get a "dummy
"Engine.